Our Story

Under New Management!

Under New Management!
Hello and welcome to "The New” Tomatoes II Pizzeria! After a thoughtful renovation, we re-opened on November 15, 2023. Join us in celebrating a fresh chapter filled with delicious flavors and a renewed commitment to our community. We are a family-owned and operated business with a simple mission: we are dedicated to providing Carnegie and the surrounding area with the finest pizza in town.

Serving the Best Pizza in Town

Serving the Best Pizza in Town
Our menu is a wonderful variety of Italian offerings all made to order, using the best products available. Our pizzas are hand-tossed and generously topped with the finest and freshest ingredients you can find; we make our sauce and dough from scratch, using the wonderful recipes handed down through generations of our family’s Italian heritage.

Casual Vibes, Serious Flavor

Casual Vibes, Serious Flavor
Waltz into Tomatoes II Pizzeria, and you'll find more than just great food. Our casual ambiance sets the stage for laid-back evenings, whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a feast. No frills, just good company and even better pizza – that's our promise.

So, what are you waiting for? Swing by 1069 Washington Ave, Carnegie, PA 15106, and become a part of the Tomatoes II Pizzeria family. We're not just serving pizza; we're serving up a slice of tradition, a dash of nostalgia, and a whole lot of flavor. Can't wait to share a table and a laugh with you! 🍕✨