Best Pizza in Carnegie

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Cheese Pizza (Large 14'' (10 Cuts))

Customize your own 14" pizza.

Add Item

Sicilian Cheese Pizza (X-Large 16'' (16 Cuts))

Classic cheese or create your own pizza

Add Item

Stuffed Crust Cheese Pizza (X-Large 16" (12 Cuts))

Classic cheese or create your own pizza

Add Item

Spinach & Chicken Pizza (X-Large 16'')

Spinach, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, your choice of red or white sauce

Add Item

Pepperoni Pillow Puffs

Sealed homemade dough filled with pepperoni and cheese, served with marinara or Ranch sauce of your choice.

Add Item

Wings

Served with ranch dressing.

Add Item

Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks

Fresh dough baked to a golden brown then topped with our special garlic sauce and Parmesan cheese.

Add Item

Savor Every Bite 🍕

Indulge in timeless favorites that never fail to satisfy at our establishment. Explore a menu featuring Gourmet and Standard Pizzas, Hoagies, Gyros, Calzones, Salads, Wings, Appetizers, and more, all crafted to perfection upon your order. Whether you prefer to savor the flavors in-house or enjoy them in the comfort of your own space, we welcome you to dine in or conveniently place an order for delivery or pick-up today!

EXPLORE MENU

Think Outside the (Pizza) Box

While our pizzas take center stage, our menu boasts an impressive array of options. Whether you're craving delectable wings, tempting pasta, flavorful gyros, cheesy quesadillas, or delightful appetizers – there's something to satisfy every palate.

Special Events & Parties: We Cater to You!

Exciting news! Our catering services are officially open and prepared to cater to your needs! Whether you're hosting a special event, a corporate gathering, or a private celebration, allow us to enhance your moments with our delectable offerings. Take a look at our menu and secure your order today. We can't wait to provide a delightful dining experience for your guests!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Cheese Pizza (Large 14'' (10 Cuts))

Customize your own 14" pizza.

Add Item

Sicilian Cheese Pizza (X-Large 16'' (16 Cuts))

Classic cheese or create your own pizza

Add Item

Stuffed Crust Cheese Pizza (X-Large 16" (12 Cuts))

Classic cheese or create your own pizza

Add Item

Spinach & Chicken Pizza (X-Large 16'')

Spinach, chicken, bacon, tomatoes, your choice of red or white sauce

Add Item

Pepperoni Pillow Puffs

Sealed homemade dough filled with pepperoni and cheese, served with marinara or Ranch sauce of your choice.

Add Item

Wings

Served with ranch dressing.

Add Item

Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks

Fresh dough baked to a golden brown then topped with our special garlic sauce and Parmesan cheese.

Add Item

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

ORDER NOW

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

I tried the Chicken Wings and Vegetarian Pizza. The taste is really good, especially their own white ranch - it's awesome. I recommend this pizza store for everyone.

Joshi J.

We ordered delivery to our hotel. We had a pepperoni pizza which was delicious. The cinnamon puffs were Awesome!! Great service, they brought it right to our room. They were so wonderful to include paper plates and napkins which I didn’t think about. Fantastic!!! Totally recommend this place!

Lisa Kretzman

Tomatoes ll is one of my favorite pizza shops in Carnegie! The quality of their food is absolutely excellent and always tastes great. I highly recommend trying their wings some time. You won’t regret it! The employees are very friendly as well🙂

Leigh A.

I was trying late night to get Pizza from my favorite place in town that doesn’t deliver and couldn’t figure it out for the life of me… That’s when I saw Tomatoes II PiZzeriA.. It was 1 minute before closing and I put in a Pepperoni Pizza order (I know, I was THAT guy). I called in to make sure it was ok, and the staff couldn’t be nicer… I couldn’t believe that this dude brought it over himself, fixed a price issue with the third party ordering service and have me a free drink (I should have just called).. Amazing service, AND I HAVE A NEW FAVORITE PIZZA IN TOWN!

Charles Knudsen

I just tried this place for the 1st time on a whim, but it's my new "go-to" pizza spot. Sicilian was outstanding, Wings with Bourbon Sauce were fantastic, and the Brownie Bites will be a standard order from now on.

William C.

I really enjoyed the Pizza and subs at Tomatoes II in Carnegie. I am always on the prowl for the best pizza in Pittsburgh and this place is a gem. Also the owner and his wife were super kind and helpful. Highly recommend.

Abby Wilcox

Italian Specialties

Tomatoes II Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Tomatoes II Pizzeria

Located at 1069 Washington Ave in Carnegie, PA, Tomatoes II Pizzeria is your neighborhood spot for comfort food done right. Swing by after work, bring the family, or make it a date – our welcoming atmosphere is perfect for all occasions.

About Us